« LA Times Tells Kids about "FIRE!" | Main | Remembering the Chief »
December 02, 2006
December Valor
Every morning, at approximately 5AM, the smell of coffee starts to fill the apparatus floors and kitchens in 103 fire stations across Los Angeles and in the basement of City Hall East (OCD - fire dispatch and Public Service). The quiet voices of firefighters and sounds of doors closing, showers, and other morning activity can be heard.
Unlike any other profession, these are the sounds of the daily shift changes at the Los Angeles Fire Department. Every morning, one of three platoons of firefighters arrive at work, to relieve those who have been on duty for the previous 24 hours. It is a routine that does not change, no matter the day, the time of year, or the weather.
Firefighters, unlike nearly any other profession, live together 24 hours at a time. It is an aspect of the job that makes it unique and unless you’ve spent a few shifts working and living with firefighters, it’s not easy to understand the bond and trust that exists between these individuals.

Firefighters must trust each other in life threatening situations
As company commanders arrive, they are briefed by their counterparts, and journals are reviewed. Emergency runs are written in red ink and in the case of important incidents that occurred for the outgoing shift, updates are provided to the incoming crews. By 6:00AM, the majority of the shift change is complete. By 8:00AM, the crews are assembled for their daily “lineup” to learn of their assignments and objectives for the coming 24 hours.
Many fire stations are busy places. In fact, Los Angeles has the busiest fire station in the country - Task Force 9 on Skid Row in downtown L.A, which responds to more than 900 runs a month or on average, 29 per day. The city overall responds to more than 1,000 calls per day, including fires, rescues, and emergency medical services.
The early morning hours are often the only time a firefighter can rest. The city is typically calmer then, and runs are more infrequent and are often EMS-related. To allow firefighters their sleep, paramedics are awakened by a “fire phone” that rings near their beds, rather than the typical long ring and “lights on” that activates most fire companies.
And so it was, in the early morning hours of December 4th, 1984. The city was fairly quiet. Around 4:45AM, L.A. Airport Police Officers Joe Ransfer and Robert Lopez were on patrol around the LAX area. The night was coming to its conclusion and the sky was less than an hour from the light of day. As they drove down South Aviation Boulevard, they noticed an orange glow of light. Looking to the east side of the street, they were surprised to see flames reaching for the early morning sky, piercing through the roof of a well known area restaurant, the Proud Bird. The two officers radioed in their report of fire in at 4:53AM.
Less than one minute later, OCD issued a structure fire assignment. The long ring came in at Task Forces 95 and 5, Engine 80 and Battalion 4. As Battalion Chief Kenneth Brass arrived on scene, it was clear the 130 foot by 175 foot ballroom was heavily involved with fire. The Chief’s size-up of the fire scene resulted in additional assignment of 23 fire companies and chief officers, including Assistant Chief Dave Parsons and Deputy Chief Don Anthony.
Unknown to firefighters at the time, the Proud Bird fire had been intentionally set to cover up a burglary. The fire had been active for several hours before it was detected. Worse, the Proud Bird was positioned directly under the flight path for LAX, and extensive work had been done to reduce noise in the restaurant, resulting in a labyrinth of difficult spaces to access and creating a dangerous fuel-rich environment for fire.

Flames shoot from the Proud Bird Restaurant
Fire companies executed an aggressive assault on the fire, with Truck companies working to open the structure, both via doorways and the roof, although roof ventilation was extremely difficult, due to the sound-proofing construction in place. As a result, the heat within the Proud Bird was intense and continued to increase.
Around 5:30AM, Engine 54 was working to advance a hose line into the ballroom. Captain Jim DiGrado and his crew, Walter Barnett and Benjamin Pinel were advancing their inch and a half line, while another Captain, Charles Mackie cleared furniture. The heat made it difficult to breath, even with SCBAs and the smoke that was unable to vent billowing down to the ground, obscuring visibility.
Suddenly, a flash-over fire-balled across the ceiling of the ballroom. The fire attack companies retreated from the building. Even in those few seconds, they became sickened by smoke and heat and once outside, paused to evaluate their situation. It was only then that they realized one of their members, Benjamin Pinel, was not with them. Pinel was still in the violently burning building.
A number of firefighters began an urgent search and rescue mission to find Pinel, among them, Johnny Garcia of Truck 64. Garcia followed the hose line that lay on the ground. It was hot and he couldn’t see more than a few feet. He was crawling on the floor to stay under the smoke and high temperature - and in the distance, he could hear the warning ringing of a firefighter’s PAL device, but couldn’t tell exactly where it was coming from.
When he was about three quarters of the way towards the hose line nozzle, Garcia realized he was alone. The other firefighters who had entered the building with him were nowhere to be seen. Following the hose line, he backed out of the building. His air was nearly gone and he didn’t know why the other firefighters had retreated, so his training compelled him to get out and evaluate himself.
Once he realized he was okay, he asked for another air bottle, and had to wait while the one on his back was hosed off, as it was too hot to touch, even with gloves. With a new bottle, Garcia again entered the building to find his fellow firefighter. This time, he made it to the nozzle and tried to listen for Pinel’s PAL device. Although he could hear the saws on the roof and the other activities of fire fighting, there was no sound from Pinel.
Garcia repeated this process three times. He nearly passed out twice. He got caught on furniture and was nearly trapped. And again, he was forced to retreat for fresh air. On his fourth attempt, Garcia began to lose his orientation. His head was heavy and his vision blurred. He began to feel confused and again following his training, tried to crawl to the exit - but this time, he came to being pulled from the building by other firefighters. Worn out, Garcia sat on the curb with oxygen, dismayed that Pinel had not been found.
A few minutes later, Garcia watched as Pinel was brought from the building and placed on a gurney, while firefighters performed CPR. The Rescue Ambulance took off for Centinela Hospital, where Pinel was pronounced dead at 6:30AM. Pinel had been found approximately 75 feet from the end of the nozzle, apparently disoriented when the flash-over occurred. For all members of the LAFD, his sacrifice 22 years ago this December 4th, has never been forgotten.

Mike (left) and Benjamin (right) Pinel at Ben's Tower Graduation
Garcia’s training no doubt saved his life. He was awarded the Medal of Value for his attempts to rescue Pinel. The physically demanding process of making your way through the tower as a rookie is intended to ensure that anyone who pins on the badge and takes the oath can uphold that oath, not just at graduation, but for years, perhaps decades to follow. The LAFD trains continually, and there is little time for recreation. When an opportunity does present itself, the activities are competitive and peer-bonding - as trust and teamwork are critical to the job.
Each firefighter in every station must rely on their fellow firefighters, regardless of background, race, or sex, to be there for not only the community, but for themselves in times of need. The everyday events in managing emergencies can become routine, but the life-threatening and sudden events that take place in a major emergency require complete trust in those about you. Every firefighter must be ready to give up their life to save another - and at the same time, be prepared to assist another firefighter who is down.
The Proud Bird fire is an important example of firefighters doing whatever it takes to save lives and property. The loss of Benjamin Pinel was a a tragedy not only for his family and the department, but for the city as a whole. At the same time, the lessons learned from this fire, and from every major emergency, are what make the LAFD so unique in terms of operations and life safety.
Today, you can see firefighter Pinel’s name on the memorial wall at the Los Angeles Fire Department’s Fallen Firefighter Memorial in Hollywood. Firefighter Garcia is still on the job and there are retired and active department members at the museum, just next to the memorial, who can explain more about how this department works to protect every citizen and every building, twenty four hours a day, seven days a week. And every firefighter knows that each day, as he or she arrives for work around 5:30AM, that this could be their Proud Bird day.
Posted by dbarrett at December 2, 2006 01:55 AM
Comments
Thank you for this wonderful story. The events of the past week may have distracted people from knowing how important our firefighters are. While there are are firefighters pro and con on the issue of Chief Bamattre's early retirement, it's clear our firefighters are the best trained anywhere. That speaks to the Chief's abilities more than any other issue. Hopefully, the mayor understands that the issues of men and women who live together is larger than one firefighter or one lawsuit. The city must work together in all areas, from the controller to the fire commission to the city attorney's office to make these changes a reality. In my opinion, the mayor, who came into office as the "great communicator" and "team builder" has failed just a bit by letting the Chief leave under these circumstances. It's probably appropriate that given the circumstances he does leave, but so much could have been done earlier, without the political turmoil that we all must work to resolve now. Thank you for this story as it brings back into focus the importance of what our tax dollars really are for: our public service agencies.
Posted by: Jennifer Patrick at December 3, 2006 02:35 AM
Good story. Garcia was and is a hero. Thank goodness we live in L.A.
Posted by: Mike Rameriz at December 3, 2006 02:59 AM
Thank you for this story. After reading this story, I have such strong feelings for our firefighters. They put so much at risk to keep us safe - and apparently, most of us take that for granted.
Posted by: Harriett Collins at December 3, 2006 02:59 PM
Thanks to people like you Mr.Barret, individuals like Benjamin Pinel will always be remembered for paying the ultimate price as a Los Angeles City Fireman. For those friends and especially family December 4,1983 will always be etched in our minds. A reminder of how fragile we really are. Ben's legacy as a Friend to all he embrased a brother and father is still alive and well in our hearts forever. I would also like us to remember all Fire/Police and Armed Forces who have laied down their lives for the purpose of serving others. God Bless
Posted by: Brother at December 5, 2006 01:01 AM
Dear Pinel Brother (and family):
Ben's story is an important one. It's wonderful that Ben's brothers both serve the city of Los Angeles as firefighters. Thank you for your kind blog comment. Benjamin and his contribution to the community while serving as a firefighter will never be forgotten and we'll all work to ensure that. And, thank you for your visits to the memorial wall. I've seen you there and it has moved me more than you might know.
Posted by: David Barrett at December 5, 2006 01:44 AM
Thank you for this story. From where I sit, it seems that firemen need a lot of faith. They don't know who they'll work with or who will be next to them in a fire.
I have been to the museum and it is wonderful. The retired firemen who created the content have done a remarkable job. It is important that we not take our firemen for granted and the recent politics in the city did just that - it reduced the value that needs to be placed on firemen (men and women). God Bless.
Posted by: Jerry Melville at December 6, 2006 04:51 PM
To all of those who have never forgotten my brother Ben and especially Johnny Garcia. I am Ben's youngest sister. I have never met you but I hope to have the honor of meeting you. You and all the people that tried to help will always be in my heart. My brother Ben was the world to me and knowing that you tried to save him will never be forgotten. After so many years it seems like yesterday. There is not one day that passes that I do not think of him. Thank you,and all those who continue to put their lives on the line. You will never be forgotten and forever have a place in my heart. God bless you all and someday may you know the comfort that you have given my mother and family. LAFD is the finest fire department and I am so proud that my brothers continue to serve such a department. Thank you.
Posted by: Yolanda Pinel at December 6, 2006 10:01 PM
I cried after reading this story. When men and women can set aside their personal issues to risk their lives to save another, it speaks to the true nature of who we are as human beings.
Posted by: Brenda Olivia at December 17, 2006 04:18 PM
David,
Once again, I offer a tip o' the helmet to you and the wonderful members of the LAFD Museum and Memorial for an article that captures and shares the spirit of our agency, and our beloved Brother Ben.
Though technical matters prevented me from providing a link during the month of December, I was pleased to feature your insightful post at the LAFD News & Information blog in early January.
I hope many people will join me in bookmarking the your home page, so as to learn and be inspired by the fascination history of the Los Angeles Fire Department.
Respectfully Yours in Safety and Service,
Brian Humphrey
Firefighter/Specialist
Public Service Officer
Los Angeles Fire Department
Posted by: Brian Humphrey at January 7, 2007 05:05 AM
Yolanda,
Your kind words touch us deeply. Please know that your brother Ben's sacrifice in the service of others will never be forgotten.
Respectfully Yours in Safety and Service,
Brian Humphrey
Firefighter/Specialist
Public Service Officer
Los Angeles Fire Department
Posted by: Brian Humphrey at January 7, 2007 05:13 AM
Thank you for this article.
Posted by: Ashley Rogers at January 7, 2007 06:26 AM
To all of you that did not know Ben you missed out on knowing a very special person. I worked with Ben in his painting business before he became a fire fighter, and his brother and I are best friends. Ben comes from a very close family who thought the world of him. In fact everyone that knew him had nothing but good things to say about him. When I worked with Ben he always took care of me, kept me working, kept money in my pocket and we did a lot of water skiing together. He was a true friend. The day I got hired as a fire fighter was to be a happy day for me. But it turned tragic, as for the day I got offered my job I also received news of Ben's death. I never got to tell Ben of my accomplishment but I do believe he is looking down and knows. This is a day I never forget and I always think of Ben and the good times we had. The LAFD lost a good man.
Posted by: John Golden,Captain Montebello Fire Department at January 7, 2007 07:59 PM
Great Article, For those who have not yet been to the LAFD Musuem & Memorial in Hollywood I highly suggest you go, It's a great expierence
Posted by: Tim at January 8, 2007 07:38 AM
Very well written story. Thanks for sharing this tragic tale.
Posted by: Seth Granville at January 12, 2007 03:11 AM
This Is a true sign of brotherhood! It is great to know that he never wanted to leave him, but just get him out by any means! His courage is truly appreciated. May God continue to watch over those who He have ordained to do such a job....
Posted by: Steve Bartholomew at January 12, 2007 03:54 AM